Monkey King: Hero Is Back and Cultural Gaps
I recently watched a Chinese movie called Monkey King: Hero Is Back in English, or 大圣归来 (Da Sheng Guilai) in Chinese (full name: 西游记之大圣归来). The name 大圣 is short for 齐天大圣, which is another name for 孙悟空, the “Monkey King” character from Journey to the West (西游记).
Have I lost you yet? This is actually a pretty good movie, with high-quality animation, but it’s written for a Chinese audience, and as such has a lot of cultural assumptions built in. Although I’m generally familiar with the story of Journey to the West (西游记), it’s a classic that every native-born Chinese person is intimately familiar with from childhood, so foreigners trying to understand the story are at a bit of a disadvantage. (I’m going to provide all the Chinese characters and pinyin for Chinese learners like I always do, but the following info should still help even if you’re not studying Chinese. Mouse over characters for pinyin.)
Pretty much every Chinese person, young and old, knows that Journey to the West has 4 main heroes (plus a horse). One annoying thing is that each character has multiple Chinese names and multiple English translations of those names. The names given in parentheses (in bold) are the ones I hear used the most by Chinese friends.
- 唐僧 (Tang Seng), AKA 唐三藏, 玄奘, or Tripitaka in English. He’s a Buddhist monk on a mission to retrieve the sacred sutra from the West. He’s the one that always wears the tall hat.
- 孙悟空 (Sun Wukong), AKA 齐天大圣, the Monkey King, also called just “Monkey” in some translations. He’s a badass rebel with an attitude that can do all sorts of magic, including taking on 72 different forms.
- 猪八戒 (Zhu Bajie), AKA “Pigsy.” Once an immortal, but now a greedy pig-man with magical powers, but only 36 forms.
- 沙悟净 (Sha Wujing), AKA Friar Sand or “Sandy.” Also a fallen immortal, he’s in the shape of a man, but he only knows 18 forms. He seems to be the lackey of the group, and is often seen hauling around everyone’s luggage. (Not nearly as famous or beloved as the above 3 characters.)
- 玉龙 AKA 白龙马 (“White Dragon Horse”), a white dragon and son of the Dragon King. Takes the form of Tang Seng’s steed as atonement for a crime. (Not nearly as famous or beloved as the top 3 characters.)
OK, now how do these traditional characters fit into the new movie 大圣归来 (Da Sheng Guilai)? That’s key to understanding it. I won’t give any real spoilers, but the following are a few important notes that all Chinese viewers understand immediately, which should clear a few things up for foreign viewers:
- The movie kicks off with Sun Wukong starting a brawl in heaven. He’s basically a troublemaker and is pissing everyone off. You get a taste of his full power here, and also see him change form.
- In the end of the opening heavenly brawl, Sun Wukong is stopped by 佛祖 (the Big Buddha), and imprisoned for 500 years under a mountain. This detail is faithful to the original.
- When Sun Wukong is first released from imprisonment, he is surprised to discover that he’s lost most of his powers, and it seems to be that magical shackle thing holding them back.
- Sun Wukong is referred to in the movie by three names/titles: 齐天大圣, 大圣, and 孙悟空.
- 唐僧, the main monk on a mission in Journey to the West, is the little boy named 江流儿 in the new movie. This name is made up for the new movie, and making him into a little boy has no basis in the original story; it’s a fresh twist. He is often referred to by Chinese audiences, for convenience, as 小唐僧 (Little Tang Seng). Everyone knows who he’s supposed to be.
- The old man that takes care of Little Tang Seng and raises him to be a monk is just created for convenience in this adaptation, as is the little girl that Little Tang Seng is protecting.
- Sun Wukong and Zhu Bajie are represented pretty faithfully to tradition in this movie.
- The “White Dragon Horse” makes a few appearances in this new movie, but he has not yet become Tang Seng’s steed. (That will probably happen in a sequel.)
- Sha Wujing does not make an appearance in this new movie. (That will also probably happen in a sequel.)
If you’re studying Chinese, I recommend you check out this movie. It’s pretty easy to follow even without the above information, but it’s nice to know how it “plugs into” contemporary Chinese culture.
I hope the forthcoming English-dubbed version is better than this:
Music video with scenes from the movie:
Additional Links:
– 西游记之大圣归来 on Baidu (Chinese)
– Monkey King: Hero Is Back on IMDb
– Monkey King: Hero Is Back on Wikipedia
– Journey to the West on Wikipedia
re: Tang Seng = Jiang Liu’er– my Chinese friends on the way out of the theater were discussing how odd it was that Tang Seng was NOT in the movie–so maybe it’s not quite so obvious?
In general, I thought the animation was good, but the story was lacking. Sort of the way I often feel about Chinese movies–technically fine, but still lacking a truly coherent story. I always feel like this might be due to my own Chinese limitations, except that most Chinese I talk to feel the same way.
Interesting. I’ve discussed the movie with a number of Chinese friends, and they found the “Little Tang Seng” quite obvious. Maybe these friends of yours were a bit young?
But yeah, I agree about the story. I wasn’t expecting much story-wise, but the animation quality exceeded my expectations.
College and grad students.
Depressing, the lack of diversity in this movie. All the same, lack of other cultures. Disheartening, if China can’t do it, then who can?
I’d say this is one of the few Chinese stories where you SHOULDN’T expect a lot of diversity. This is a traditional Chinese story, after all.
What kind of diversity were you hoping for?
I think people who have read the original copy of Journey to the West in Chinese version are more likely to recognize Jiang Liu’er as Tangseng, because Tangseng once was called Jiang liu (and sometimes ‘er’ means nothing in Chinese like this one here 😉 ). ‘Jiangliu’ means ‘flowing down the river’ in Chinese. And in the novel, Tangseng’s mother had put him in a wooden basin, kind of abandoning him in a river for some complex reasons. And the old man(btw, the old man was in the original as well, called Fǎmíng) found Tangsen flowing down a river and brought him up and hence called him Jiangliu. In the movie, Little Tang Seng’s name was also taken alike I suppose 😉